
Introduction:
India has the second largest population in the world, and if current trends continue they will overtake China and become the most populated country in the world. However their national football team is far from successful. According to the latest FIFA World rankings the Indian national football team is ranked 162nd in the world.
The mission of the All India Football Federation (AIFF) is “to engender an entertaining and high quality football league that engages hundreds of millions of fans, drives improvement in playing standards and delivers value for all partners.” In addition to this the vision of the AIFF is for “India to become a global football power and qualify for the 2026 FIFA World Cup.”
History of Indian football:
Football was bought to India through British regiments and missionaries, especially in the Calcutta region, in the 1870’s. From this time forth football quickly became a marker of nationalist identity and community against British imperialism.
India has previously qualified for a World Cup and this was the 1950 World Cup. However they didn’t participate. One particular theory suggests that they were not allowed to play barefoot, so India relinquished their position in the tournament. However, and possibly, a more adequate reason to why they didn’t participate was due to financial restraints and alongside this India prioritized the Olympic games in 1950 as they hosted this competition.
In 1996 the AIFF created the Indian National Football League (NFL). This was to be a semi professional league and they had signed up a ten-year broadcasting deal with Rupert Murdoch’s Star TV. This was worth $1million a year.
In 2006 this was changed to the I-League. The aim behind this was to improve standards and implement full professionalization of the game. Meaning an introduction of more competition, the I-League 2nd division. The AIFF also signed a 10-year broadcasting agreement with Zee sports (an Indian broadcasting company). However in 2010 the AIFF terminated this contract with Zee sports (four years early) and sold full commercial rights (exclusive commercial rights to sponsorship, advertising, broadcasting, merchandising, video, franchising, and rights to create a new football league) to IMG (a global sports management company) for $105 million over fifteen years. However IMG continually struggled to sell these commercial rights. In the end they decided to create an MLS (Major League Soccer- USA) style, Indian Super League with eight franchises. Star Sports is a sports broadcasting which is huge in Asia and they bought 35% of the ISL for USD $300m million. This subsequently has solved the problem of selling broadcasting rights.
Indian Super League comparison with Cricket in India:
Cricket is seen as a religion in India, so does football really stand a chance? Cricket is very popular in the media, in advertising and most of India’s idols are from cricket.
When discussing a comparison between Cricket and Football, the following points are important. Firstly it cost $1.95Bn for the Indian Premier League (cricket and IPL) to be created. In addition to this the TV deal (for 10 years) for Sony Television and World Sport Group was $1Billion. The money mentioned in the previous section about football is much less than the money mentioned here in terms of the capital to create the IPL.
However it can be said that football is improving in its comparison with cricket and this is due to the ISL. The financial security offered by the league is essential to promoting football as a viable career option. The ISL today has 17 central sponsors. This kind of sponsor interest in football has never been seen in India before. This suggests that one, the football market is growing in India (and potentially challenging cricket), and two, football in India can be a serious occupation for Indian people. Furthermore the number of sponsors is ever increasing and this will of course lead to further positive viewership of the league.
League Structure:
India already had a football league structure in place (The I-League and I-League 2nd division) and according to FIFA rules a country is not allowed more than one national league structure in a country. However FIFA does not ‘officially’ recognize the ISL as a national league. According to the AIFF president, FIFA gave India ‘special dispensation’ to start this tournament. The ISL was initially planned to start in January 2014, however due to complications such as the availability of players and readiness of the tournament, the start date had to be postponed for nine months.
With that clubs playing in the I-League (India’s recognized national football league) opposing the creation of a new league, it took IMG-R (IMG Reliance) a few months to finally get the required number of players for the tournament. Furthermore the I-League had its calendar delayed due to the introduction of the ISL. This has now meant that the I-League matches start in January and end in late may. This means that some matches will be played in the humid Indian summer. As well as this matches will have to be played in the afternoon due to most stadia not having the appropriate lighting facilities, these factors will have a huge negative impact on the I-League.
There are also concerns among followers of the I-League that with the marketing partners of the I-League; being IMG Reliance, who are also the organizers of the ISL there could be a probability of the sponsorships being directed over to the ISL. Therefore this would be another negative impact on the I-League. Furthermore the salaries offered by the I-League clubs are nowhere near the salaries offered by the ISL franchisees, and this could lead to the players not plying their trade in the I-League. This in turn will decrease the standards of the I-league as well as more revenues being re directed toward the ISL.
The ISL clubs don’t have any academies or a means within the club itself to develop youth, and this is with valid reason. They play for two months a year in a round robin style tournament with play offs, for the top teams in a winner takes all situation, which is good as it stops one side dominating. They do not need to risk playing young, untried and untested Indian players when they have a squad of experienced players and world famous players. In terms of the I-league as it is ‘more of a league’ all clubs have permanent and proper academies and also several prominent European clubs have recently established academies in India.
The Indian Super League:
The Indian Super League is an independent league and it is separate to the other professional football leagues in the country. It was described as being a football championship that will create and develop local talent while at the same time featuring world-renowned stars.
Negatives include, due to the lack of matches and the lack of participating teams there would be a struggle to keep, and sign good players, furthermore there is a lack of competitiveness especially as there is only one division. Another negative would be that it is a short tournament so how would players (Indian players) benefit from this and therefore how would the Indian national team improve.
There are currently eight franchises in the ISL, with each team (in accordance with the rules) contracting 14 Indian players each (minimum squad of 22 players). This takes the total number of Indian footballers in the league to 112. This gives the view that the ISL has the potential to be good for the Indian national team as a large number of the teams’ squad would be Indian.
Another good point about the ISL is the ticket prices for fans for matches. Tickets are priced as low as Rs150 ($2.37). Evidence shows that the ISL’s average attendance is 24,357, which surprisingly is only than the Bundesliga, the Premier League and La Liga. This suggests that the ISL is the fourth biggest league in the world. At the opening game of the ISL between Atlético de Kolkata and Mumbai City the attendance was a staggering 65,000. This match had an audience of 74.7 million people on television. However it is important to remain in context and in doing this, this statistic does not mean much. This is because of the number of clubs and therefore the number of matches played in the ISL are much less than compared to the Bundesliga and the other leagues mentioned.
On the most part the ISL seems to be a positive creation, however the league needs to ensure match tickets remain affordable to fans, the game remains clear and transparent, and they continue to help develop grassroots football.
Industry growing – Famous players are moving to the Indian Super League:
The ISL has been able to attract some big footballing names in its first two seasons. Very few people believed football in India would have imagined seeing the likes of Marco Materazzi, Nicolas Anelka, Roberto Carlos and Lucio play for Indian clubs. In addition it is not only players like these going to India, very reputable coaches are going over to India and providing clubs with their experience and knowledge. It must be very good for young Indian footballers to train alongside successful footballers and be educated by famous coaches. This can only benefit young Indian players and hopefully provide India with some special talent.
Recent developments in Indian football:
The ISL has recently arranged a strategic partnership with the English premier league. It has been said that the aim of this deal is to help develop the ISL. Furthermore the partnership between these two organizations would see them work closely and share knowledge in various key areas, such as “player development, refereeing, marketing and promotion”. This provides further evidence that India is looking to improve football as a whole in the country and this move can potentially have a positive impact on the national team.
Another recent development in the Indian football industry is that FIFA had agreed a four-year plan with the AIFF. The aim of this partnership is to help aid the development of football in India. However in this deal FIFA want the I-league to retain the number one league status in India in the wake of the launch of the Indian Super League.
It has been said that merging the ISL and the I-league would be good for the sport and it would be the most appropriate way of aiding the potential success of the Indian national team in future years. Whatever happens remains to be seen, but I can see the two leagues merging and therefore creating a similar football league structure to many European countries.
Conclusion:
As has been discussed there are many different variables that can have an impact on the success of the Indian National team. The growth of the Indian Super League has a huge potential to have a positive impact on the national team, however this may not be seen for at least five to ten years. Recommendations are discussed below to improve the Indian National team. I believe that if the recommendations are put into place then certainly within ten years India will be starting to compete at a much higher level than they currently do.
Recommendations:
First on foremost it would be recommended to merge the two league structures (the I-league and the ISL) into one and have at least two divisions to allow promotion and relegation. Then through this ensure each club has its own academies so it can develop young Indian talent. Although, it is important to consider that this move will be difficult, because of the discussions, which would lead to which teams go into the first or second division.
Secondly it is recommended that the AIFF build Indian football schools and populate them with experienced professional coaches who have the knowledge and the know how to produce the future football stars for India.
Furthermore it would be recommended to make football compulsory in schools, to ensure children are doing activity, not just to be healthy, but to improve their football skills. Therefore improving their chances to be chosen to go to a football school (mentioned above).
Lastly it would be recommended to continue to sign some of the world’s most renowned footballers as well as employing highly respected coaches and mangers. This would not only mean an increase in attendance but also each club’s players would be involved in training sessions of the highest caliber that would improve them as professionals.


